I just simply dont agree with the comment. Im not blinded by asthetics. I have ears. And I've done my share of mixes. Dead is not a quality I would even remotely begin to describe the tone as. Even the 305's single coil models sound great. It's one guys opinion that, in my opinion, stems from something else entirely.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
I'm sure we've all seen PRS's TedTalk on tone where he talked about guitars being subtractive instruments and how they do their best to use components that will "return" as much energy back as what has been applied to the guitar, etc (if you havent seen it go look it up on Youtube). And we all know that PRS himself believes in magical guitars where "practically all notes feed back and sounds like an ebow" to paraphrase Paul's own words (look for Paul's Youtube video of him talking about how his relationship with Carlos Santana started).
I think what OAS is referring to as "dead-sounding" are guitars which "subtract" a lot of energy which is applied to it. As PRS himself would say in his videos, "you give it 7 and it will give back 2 or 3". And "magical" guitars in turn would "subtract" very minimal energy which is applied to it so it resonates and sings and what not. As Paul himself would say, "You give it a 7 and it gives back 6.5".
I think OAS and Paul are on the same page on that. What I think they would disagree with is the 2% part.