I have the album and for me, I love it. I like it na diverse yung sounds ng Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace. Nandun pa rin yung heavy guitar riffs at driving rhythm section, screaming vocals ni Grohl and at the same time meron din mga acoustic numbers. Aside from "The Pretender" I like the tracks "Long Road To Ruin", "Come Alive", "Cheer Up, Boys (Your Make Up Is Running)" - which I read somewhere is Grohl's emo song.
Ayos din yung "Statues" and yung last track na "Home" - just Dave Grohl on piano and vocals.
I definitely recommend the album.