TALK @ PhilMusic.com - The Online Home of the Pinoy Musician

The Musician Forums => Pinoydrums => Topic started by: arien_drummer on May 18, 2010, 09:17:50 PM

Title: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: arien_drummer on May 18, 2010, 09:17:50 PM
I've got a crash on top of another crash. masama ba to? nakakasira ba to? sila vic mercado kasi ginagawa to eh. pati c weckl... masama ba to?
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: vhinming on May 18, 2010, 10:15:18 PM
I've got a crash on top of another crash. masama ba to? nakakasira ba to? sila vic mercado kasi ginagawa to eh. pati c weckl... masama ba to?
ginagawa ng pro's edi it means safe hehe IMO  :-D

ahm parang trashy po ba ang habol mo na sound? hehe
try mo po yung china and splash stack  :-)
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: daleee on May 18, 2010, 11:11:19 PM
ginagawa ng pro's edi it means safe hehe IMO  :-D

ahm parang trashy po ba ang habol mo na sound? hehe
try mo po yung china and splash stack  :-)

IMO, just because someone famous is doing it doesn't correspond to it being safe... why do we avoid metal-to-metal contacts in putting cymbals in stands? it's because it may damage the cymbal. For the stacking naman, i think ang danger na doon eh hindi na wood or nylon tip ang tumatama sa cymbal kundi isa pang cymbal, much like hitting the cymbal with Ahead sticks without the tapers, baka mayupi or numipis yung cymbal. Plus hindi masyadong na-aallow yung cymbal na magvibrate freely or magreact dun sa palo mo, so baka mas madali magcrack yung cymbal dahil dun...
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: arien_drummer on May 18, 2010, 11:26:07 PM
siguro dapat gawin to pag endorser na noh? ahahaha :lol: pag pwede na mag sira ng cymbals.ahahaha. sige. tanggalin ko na stack ko. hahahaha
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: daleee on May 18, 2010, 11:29:08 PM
siguro dapat gawin to pag endorser na noh? ahahaha :lol: pag pwede na mag sira ng cymbals.ahahaha. sige. tanggalin ko na stack ko. hahahaha

tama. kamusta pala tunog nung crashes stack mo?
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: wireme on May 18, 2010, 11:32:38 PM
i don't think masisira agad but in the long run may possibility talaga.

as for the artists, mga endorsers sila at may nagsusupply sa kanila ng mga cymbals kaya ok lang kahit masira kasi madali lang palitan.
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: plep on May 19, 2010, 12:05:43 AM
when stacked, cymbals dont get to move around naturally when hit. hindi siya maka-vibrate ng tama, kaya nasestress yung cymbal. so mas malaki ang posibilidad na magcrack.

siguro mas maganda na yung mumurahin o kaya yung sira nang cymbals ang gamitin sa stack. at least hindi malaking kawalan kung magcrack.

Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: arien_drummer on May 19, 2010, 06:53:24 AM
maganda tunog niya I'll post soundclips kung gusto niyo. trashy na may suntok. hirap i explain eh. hahahaha.

yung stack ko kasi, 15 K zildjian dark crash thin na may malaking crack (repaired by dabomb) tsaka 18 Avedis Medium thin crash na may tatlong crack sa edge (also repaired by dabomb). so... ayun. may sira na siya kaso repaired na. hehehe.
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: metalmuhlisha on May 19, 2010, 07:04:20 AM
imo definitely in the long run magkakaroon yan ng problema. pero ok lang siya kung pambahay lang, hindi naman agad agad masisira yun. pero kung pang-gig mahirap, mapalakas lang ng konti palo mo wala na.
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: plep on May 19, 2010, 07:59:11 AM
maganda tunog niya I'll post soundclips kung gusto niyo. trashy na may suntok. hirap i explain eh. hahahaha.

yung stack ko kasi, 15 K zildjian dark crash thin na may malaking crack (repaired by dabomb) tsaka 18 Avedis Medium thin crash na may tatlong crack sa edge (also repaired by dabomb). so... ayun. may sira na siya kaso repaired na. hehehe.

puro may sira na pala e! okay na yan!  :evil:
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: Gep on May 19, 2010, 08:11:13 AM
Kung trashy sound din lang ang hanap mo, then go for the cheaper alloys.
Kahit yung stacks na Noise Works ng Paiste e gawa lang sa NS12 Nickel-Silver at MS63 Brass e.
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: arien_drummer on May 19, 2010, 08:52:48 AM
wala kasi akong pera eh. hahaha. If I had money, Papatusin ko na yung mga oriental china trash sa classifieds! ahahaha. nkakainis nga eh...
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: plep on May 19, 2010, 03:58:24 PM
Kung trashy sound din lang ang hanap mo, then go for the cheaper alloys.
Kahit yung stacks na Noise Works ng Paiste e gawa lang sa NS12 Nickel-Silver at MS63 Brass e.

yung mga lumang brass na lazer, sobrang ganda pang-stack. yung 20" ko nun dati is still one of my all-time favorite cymbals (kaso sobrang punit punit na niya ngayon e, sobrang useless na). meron pa rin ako 14", 12", at 8" na ginagamit minsan na iba-ibang combination.
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: akgm52192 on May 19, 2010, 07:26:59 PM
Diba may cymbals si Portnoy na made to be stacked with each other? Yung MAX STAX(sp?) ata by sabian. ganda ng tunog nun - parang closed hihat pero china-ish yung "chick" sound dapat.
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: uy12umainer on May 20, 2010, 01:30:48 AM
dont try this im telling you, tama avoid metal to metal contact kasi masisira cymbals niyo even if splash china kahit anong gawin natin madadamage at magiiba tunog ng cymbals niyo
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: imaginaryeric on May 20, 2010, 10:20:30 AM
Never mind metal fatigue. Think about your hands. Since stacked cymbals don't open up (maybe at all), you tend to hit them harder.

It can be bad for your wrists and tendons in the long run. Though through practice you can strengthen your hands, just think about how soccer players and boxers get Parkinson's later in life.

I don't want to be a party pooper (My idol Zach Hill also has a stacked setup), but do explore for other trashy sound sources there that can be light on your budget and on your hands.
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: dolfmen on May 20, 2010, 07:25:49 PM
may mga sponsor kasi ata sila kaya may pera silang pangpalit ng mga cymbals,.  :-D
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: littlenikki on May 22, 2010, 09:58:04 AM
may na panuod ako dati sa youtube ang tawag nila dito ay "pig tailing" ata parang ganun.. pero yung iba simply stacking ang tawag..

hindi ko gano magets pano isesetup sa Stand ang ganito lalo na sa mga FELT WASHERS kasi saktong pang isang cymbals lang sila.. at dipende pa sa sleeves ng stand.

pero mukang maganda combination crash at mini china.. mukang trashy..
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: vhinming on May 25, 2010, 12:50:54 PM
IMO, just because someone famous is doing it doesn't correspond to it being safe... why do we avoid metal-to-metal contacts in putting cymbals in stands? it's because it may damage the cymbal. For the stacking naman, i think ang danger na doon eh hindi na wood or nylon tip ang tumatama sa cymbal kundi isa pang cymbal, much like hitting the cymbal with Ahead sticks without the tapers, baka mayupi or numipis yung cymbal. Plus hindi masyadong na-aallow yung cymbal na magvibrate freely or magreact dun sa palo mo, so baka mas madali magcrack yung cymbal dahil dun...

yah thanks sir, mali nga ako

pero ur right, kasi dahil sponsored sila, maybe they make experiments sa cymbals (w/c is not sure kung safe) so that kung maganda tunog, pero nakakasira, gagayahin sila then dahil unique ang way ng pro's hindi nila masisisi yung company sa pagkasira and bibili nalang sila ng new one hahahah! IMO ulit  :-D
haha
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: kssael on May 26, 2010, 06:11:12 PM
I have no experience in using stacked cymbals but combining different splashes and mini-chinas can give you a wide array of different thrashy sounds.
Title: Re: Is cymbal stacking bad?
Post by: daleee on May 26, 2010, 08:56:32 PM
yah thanks sir, mali nga ako

pero ur right, kasi dahil sponsored sila, maybe they make experiments sa cymbals (w/c is not sure kung safe) so that kung maganda tunog, pero nakakasira, gagayahin sila then dahil unique ang way ng pro's hindi nila masisisi yung company sa pagkasira and bibili nalang sila ng new one hahahah! IMO ulit  :-D
haha

pero kasi, ang ganda din talaga ng tunog ng stacked cymbals eh, katulad nalang nung kay Portnoy. Kung gipit ka naman at gusto mo talaga mag stack, bili ka nalang nung splashes at mini chinas ng Stagg, mura na ok pa tunog kung makachamba ka ng magandang combination.