TALK @ PhilMusic.com - The Online Home of the Pinoy Musician

The Music Forums => The Rock Music Board => Topic started by: skunkyfunk on October 01, 2006, 10:40:04 AM

Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians? - LOCKED
Post by: skunkyfunk on October 01, 2006, 10:40:04 AM
Eto ang ultimate LA SALLE VS. ATENEO music rivalry thread.  Kung taga UP ka, sorry pagpaliban mo muna guts mo hehehe.  

Please take note this is about high school alumni...

Anyway, here's a roundup:

LA SALLE:
Most of the Razorback dudes
Ogie Alcasid
Ira Cruz
Randy Santiago

ATENEO:
the Parokya dudes
Marc Abaya
Apo Hiking Society

Please add...
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: higad on October 01, 2006, 11:42:16 AM
Quote from: tehr0x
kung nasaan ang skychurch, cynthia alexander, radioactivesogoprogejct, the jerks, deadnails, erectus, datus tribe at.. urbandub, i doubt people care what school theyre faveouriteb ands goes/wnet to, eh.. malamang ako labfng ganito magisip


di ko naintindihan ung last part hehe
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: marko21 on October 01, 2006, 12:20:58 PM
ateneo
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: tripnotic on October 01, 2006, 09:07:39 PM
hanggang sa pag produce ba naman ng musicians meron pa rin competition dito. hindi naman school ang may talent. so no matter what school youre from as long as you have what it takes youll be successful.
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: kuyaneo on October 01, 2006, 09:09:37 PM
hmm sa ateneo:
si nino avenido(greyhoundz)<- not sure pero sa pagkaka alam ko
si mike elgar(rivermaya)
si yani yuzon(pupil)
sponge cola dudes(kahit ayaw ko sa kanila mga atenista din sila)
dicta license
Narda
nakalimutan ko na ung ibang alumni
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: blue buddha on October 01, 2006, 10:25:55 PM
hmm sa la salle (in addition to those mentioned above):

gary valenciano
meong pacana (ugoy ugoy)
joey quirino (keyboard genius, everyone's go-to guy)
vic borgailly (ko jones, blue rats)
johnny besa (the breed, blue rats)
kakoi legaspi (mr. crayon, river maya, salindiwa)
.....
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: tam_guitar on October 01, 2006, 11:31:12 PM
bkt la salle at ateneo lang ang choices?
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: spilledmilk on October 02, 2006, 07:44:46 AM
panu naman mapuyat institulog of antoknology...alam ko we're all about math equations and numbers...pero i know marami marunong tumugtog samin...(ewan ko lang ngaun...pero nung batch ko marami trasher na tambay sa gilid...sa "hardkur alley" hehehe)
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: Gep on October 02, 2006, 09:58:28 AM
Kailangan bang magbilang dito?
O sige para ma-satisfy ang competitive nature mo, ito ang mga naging sikat na bandang may nag-Ateneo high:

Dicta License, Itchyworms, Ciudad, Boldstar, Sponge Cola, Boy Elroy, Greyhoundz, 13 Needles, Plane Divides the Sky, Descant Gott, Sponge Cola, Rampqueen, Sugarfree (pero wala na si Mitch), Narda
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: toybitz on October 02, 2006, 05:31:39 PM
Quote from: blue buddha
hmm sa la salle (in addition to those mentioned above):

gary valenciano
meong pacana (ugoy ugoy)
joey quirino (keyboard genius, everyone's go-to guy)
vic borgailly (ko jones, blue rats)
johnny besa (the breed, blue rats)
kakoi legaspi (mr. crayon, river maya, salindiwa)
.....


Daniel Crislogo
Dave Aguirre
Miguel Ortigas
nino mendoza
miggy matute (Maegan Aguilar, Blue Jean Junkies)
yun guitarista ng Velcro (nalmutan ko na pangalan mo, sori, kabatch pa man din)
si Mark Escueta(RMaya)
Papa Dom
Francis Reyes (La Salle Lipa)
Dingdong Avanzado (tama ba apelyido?)
Eric Hernanandez (Huka, Mr. crayon, Blue Jean Junkies)
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: toybitz on October 02, 2006, 05:32:42 PM
Quote from: Gep
Kailangan bang magbilang dito?
O sige para ma-satisfy ang competitive nature mo, ito ang mga naging sikat na bandang may nag-Ateneo high:

Dicta License, Itchyworms, Ciudad, Boldstar, Sponge Cola, Boy Elroy, Greyhoundz, 13 Needles, Plane Divides the Sky, Descant Gott, Sponge Cola, Rampqueen, Sugarfree (pero wala na si Mitch), Narda


Backdraft, mga batchmates ko.
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: zook on October 02, 2006, 06:54:58 PM
Quote from: toybitz
Quote from: Gep
Kailangan bang magbilang dito?
O sige para ma-satisfy ang competitive nature mo, ito ang mga naging sikat na bandang may nag-Ateneo high:
Dicta License, Itchyworms, Ciudad, Boldstar, Sponge Cola, Boy Elroy, Greyhoundz, 13 Needles, Plane Divides the Sky, Descant Gott, Sponge Cola, Rampqueen, Sugarfree (pero wala na si Mitch), Narda

Backdraft, mga batchmates ko.

Aya Yuson, batch '89.
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: zook on October 02, 2006, 06:58:06 PM
Quote from: toybitz
Quote from: Gep
Kailangan bang magbilang dito?
O sige para ma-satisfy ang competitive nature mo, ito ang mga naging sikat na bandang may nag-Ateneo high:

Dicta License, Itchyworms, Ciudad, Boldstar, Sponge Cola, Boy Elroy, Greyhoundz, 13 Needles, Plane Divides the Sky, Descant Gott, Sponge Cola, Rampqueen, Sugarfree (pero wala na si Mitch), Narda

Backdraft, mga batchmates ko.

The late Teddy Diaz came from the AGS and AHS.
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: blue buddha on October 02, 2006, 11:20:14 PM
Quote from: tam_guitar
bkt la salle at ateneo lang ang choices?


Dahil these are the only two schools who produce guys juvenile enough to ask juvenile questions like this and who are so juvenile as to carry on lifelong juvenile rivalries like this.  :lol:  (la sallista ako and my best friends are atenistas so I should know).  :wink: Kulturang pinoy 'yan. The classic rivalries: Kanino ka, Nora or Vilma? Pip or Bot? Makoy or Cory? Bogs or Jaworski? Crispa or Toyota? Inquirer or Star? ABS-CBN or GMA? Tancho Tique or Three Flowers Pomade? Royal or Mirinda? Sampaguita Pictures or LVN? John or Marsha?

If the lists are accurate, there's an emerging pattern here it seems....
• Better Bands = Ateneo
• Better Musicians = La Salle
• Bands who get hired = Ateneo
• Musicians who bands hire = La Salle
• Musicians who hire the bands = La Salle

Interesting. :lol:
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: blues2death on October 03, 2006, 01:33:43 AM
sa pop naman dahil tungkol naman sa school ang thread

ateneo--ung si bondoc na gitarista na pop...sino nga ba yun?a ok
            jimmy bondoc.

la salle gh--paco a.(introvoys)

la salle zobel--jay padua(overtone,norby david(overtone)G3 misa

i dont know anymore musicians kasi d naman ako la salle or ateneo.kung bene,ust ang labanan--mga sessionista na musikero madami.
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: riffscreamer on October 03, 2006, 10:56:23 AM
Teka lang, di pa kami sikat eh. Iba-ibang college na kami ngayon ng mga kabanda ko, pero lahat kami galing DLSZ. Haha.
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: akosimic on October 03, 2006, 11:21:38 AM
yup nino avenido is from admu.

add nyo na rin:

monkespank - la salle greenhills

pero yung may label na "ateneo" or "la salle" or "ust" band ang kinaiinisan ko para samin. true we came from a certain school (in our case ateneo and ust and now half dlsu), pero its something na we dont realy flaunt because we showcase our stuff outside school most of the time.
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: blue buddha on October 03, 2006, 12:29:22 PM
Tulad ng earlier post -- it's a juvenile question....  :lol:
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: toybitz on October 03, 2006, 01:15:11 PM
Quote from: blue buddha
Quote from: tam_guitar
bkt la salle at ateneo lang ang choices?


Dahil these are the only two schools who produce guys juvenile enough to ask juvenile questions like this and who are so juvenile as to carry on lifelong juvenile rivalries like this.  :lol:  (la sallista ako and my best friends are atenistas so I should know).  :wink: Kulturang pinoy 'yan. The classic rivalries: Kanino ka, Nora or Vilma? Pip or Bot? Makoy or Cory? Bogs or Jaworski? Crispa or Toyota? Inquirer or Star? ABS-CBN or GMA? Tancho Tique or Three Flowers Pomade? Royal or Mirinda? Sampaguita Pictures or LVN? John or Marsha?

kanta ni Dong Abay ito ah..
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: franco on October 03, 2006, 01:57:13 PM
Quote
kanta ni Dong Abay ito ah
 :lol:  sakto!

Quote
who produces better musicians?


better musicians? under what preference? iba-iba kc panlasa ng tao pero tama si blue buddha, mas madaming nahhire na bands from ahs. siguro the biggest factor would be katipunan, pero ewan ko ba kung bakit ko nasabi yun  :roll:
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: jun_BALARAW on October 03, 2006, 04:19:29 PM
parang mali mga sir... hindi naman kasi tinuturo ang pagbabanda sa skul eh..

tingin ko bago pa lang pumasok sa college eh may mga banda na yang mga yan..

opinion ko lang...
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: Anna; on October 03, 2006, 07:18:52 PM
Quote from: blue buddha


If the lists are accurate, there's an emerging pattern here it seems....
• Better Bands = Ateneo
• Better Musicians = La Salle
• Bands who get hired = Ateneo
• Musicians who bands hire = La Salle
• Musicians who hire the bands = La Salle

Interesting. :lol:


i couldn't agree more.
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: marko21 on October 03, 2006, 09:25:05 PM
Quote from: jun_BALARAW
parang mali mga sir... hindi naman kasi tinuturo ang pagbabanda sa skul eh..

tingin ko bago pa lang pumasok sa college eh may mga banda na yang mga yan..

opinion ko lang...
yep! tama..depende naman yan sa skul na papasukan ng mga talented na musicians eh..
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: riffscreamer on October 04, 2006, 09:21:45 AM
From La Salle Zobel. Basti Artadi, Mayonnaise, yung bassist ng Bamboo(kaso kickout. nyahaha)
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: jun_BALARAW on October 04, 2006, 09:36:56 AM
Quote from: marko21
Quote from: jun_BALARAW
parang mali mga sir... hindi naman kasi tinuturo ang pagbabanda sa skul eh..

tingin ko bago pa lang pumasok sa college eh may mga banda na yang mga yan..

opinion ko lang...
yep! tama..depende naman yan sa skul na papasukan ng mga talented na musicians eh..

kasi hindi porke magaaral ka sa isang university eh gagaling ka na tumugtog... diba???
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: Gep on October 04, 2006, 10:46:04 AM
Quote from: jun_BALARAW
Quote from: marko21
Quote from: jun_BALARAW
parang mali mga sir... hindi naman kasi tinuturo ang pagbabanda sa skul eh..

tingin ko bago pa lang pumasok sa college eh may mga banda na yang mga yan..

opinion ko lang...
yep! tama..depende naman yan sa skul na papasukan ng mga talented na musicians eh..

kasi hindi porke magaaral ka sa isang university eh gagaling ka na tumugtog... diba???


Oo nga.
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: marko21 on October 04, 2006, 06:11:06 PM
yeah. hindi naman nagtuturo ng music yung mga colleges diba. saka depende rin yan sa mga pinagmulan nung banda.. :lol:
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: drumster on October 05, 2006, 03:58:09 PM
I think it's a matter of school pride.  It's not about competition and who is better, and it really doesn't matter where a musician is/was enrolled.  As long as a musician is an exceptional artist & he/she does it right with his craft, that's what matters to me.


Speaking of school pride...  Here are a few friends of mine from La Salle who have made their marks in the music scene (Some were already mentioned, but I'll just list them down again):

David Aguirre (LSGH HS '96)
Barbie Almalbis
JunJun Regalado (session drummer)
Mark Escueta (Rivermaya)
original members of Passage
Daniel Crisologo
Jay Padua and Norby David (Overtone)
Paolo Manuel (drummer)
Nyoy Volante


I may be a Lasallian, but I also admire plenty of great musicians who studied in other great schools.

Simply be proud of your Alma Mater.

 8)
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: tam_guitar on October 05, 2006, 05:00:22 PM
Quote from: toybitz
Quote from: blue buddha
Quote from: tam_guitar
bkt la salle at ateneo lang ang choices?


Dahil these are the only two schools who produce guys juvenile enough to ask juvenile questions like this and who are so juvenile as to carry on lifelong juvenile rivalries like this.  :lol:  (la sallista ako and my best friends are atenistas so I should know).  :wink: Kulturang pinoy 'yan. The classic rivalries: Kanino ka, Nora or Vilma? Pip or Bot? Makoy or Cory? Bogs or Jaworski? Crispa or Toyota? Inquirer or Star? ABS-CBN or GMA? Tancho Tique or Three Flowers Pomade? Royal or Mirinda? Sampaguita Pictures or LVN? John or Marsha?

kanta ni Dong Abay ito ah..


ganun poh ba yun?

parang closeup or colgate?
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: tam_guitar on October 05, 2006, 05:02:30 PM
Quote from: toybitz
Quote from: blue buddha
Quote from: tam_guitar
bkt la salle at ateneo lang ang choices?


Dahil these are the only two schools who produce guys juvenile enough to ask juvenile questions like this and who are so juvenile as to carry on lifelong juvenile rivalries like this.  :lol:  (la sallista ako and my best friends are atenistas so I should know).  :wink: Kulturang pinoy 'yan. The classic rivalries: Kanino ka, Nora or Vilma? Pip or Bot? Makoy or Cory? Bogs or Jaworski? Crispa or Toyota? Inquirer or Star? ABS-CBN or GMA? Tancho Tique or Three Flowers Pomade? Royal or Mirinda? Sampaguita Pictures or LVN? John or Marsha?

kanta ni Dong Abay ito ah..


ganun poh ba yun?

parang closeup or colgate?
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: tam_guitar on October 05, 2006, 05:02:32 PM
Quote from: toybitz
Quote from: blue buddha
Quote from: tam_guitar
bkt la salle at ateneo lang ang choices?


Dahil these are the only two schools who produce guys juvenile enough to ask juvenile questions like this and who are so juvenile as to carry on lifelong juvenile rivalries like this.  :lol:  (la sallista ako and my best friends are atenistas so I should know).  :wink: Kulturang pinoy 'yan. The classic rivalries: Kanino ka, Nora or Vilma? Pip or Bot? Makoy or Cory? Bogs or Jaworski? Crispa or Toyota? Inquirer or Star? ABS-CBN or GMA? Tancho Tique or Three Flowers Pomade? Royal or Mirinda? Sampaguita Pictures or LVN? John or Marsha?

kanta ni Dong Abay ito ah..


ganun poh ba yun?

parang closeup or colgate?
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: blue buddha on October 05, 2006, 10:50:59 PM
....Listerine o Astring-o-sol, Sarao o Francisco Motors, Globe o Smart.....  #-o
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: toybitz on October 06, 2006, 05:58:42 PM
Quote from: tam_guitar
Quote from: toybitz
Quote from: blue buddha
Quote from: tam_guitar
bkt la salle at ateneo lang ang choices?


Dahil these are the only two schools who produce guys juvenile enough to ask juvenile questions like this and who are so juvenile as to carry on lifelong juvenile rivalries like this.  :lol:  (la sallista ako and my best friends are atenistas so I should know).  :wink: Kulturang pinoy 'yan. The classic rivalries: Kanino ka, Nora or Vilma? Pip or Bot? Makoy or Cory? Bogs or Jaworski? Crispa or Toyota? Inquirer or Star? ABS-CBN or GMA? Tancho Tique or Three Flowers Pomade? Royal or Mirinda? Sampaguita Pictures or LVN? John or Marsha?

kanta ni Dong Abay ito ah..


ganun poh ba yun?

parang closeup or colgate?


muntik na Tam, hindi lang inulit ni Dong ng 3 beses yun linyang iyan.  :lol:

sayang Bro, hindi kita na meet nun EB, pero ikaw nga ata yung nakaupo sa harap namin ni Deacon Blues, parang dalawa kayo eh, na sa gitna.  tama ba?
Title: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: drummer_boy17 on October 06, 2006, 08:39:35 PM
Parehas lng naman eh.. :)
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: ioffendpeople on October 28, 2006, 06:32:22 PM
I'm from La Salle Green Hills here...from what I've heard, these guys are really talented, but the music they play is really boring.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: roger_alcantara on October 31, 2006, 09:37:37 AM
Pepe Manikan of Eternal Now (LSGH)
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: the emo poser on October 31, 2006, 11:00:25 AM
You know, I have to get into this discussion because I currently am an Ateneo High School student.




Actually,I rarely hear any La Salle Greenhill "Bands".I know a lot guys from La Salle WHO became pop artists.



Also,being a new student,ayos yung nakita ko na marunong nang mag gitara yung mga 1st year...
Me future....................In fact,andami nangang me gigs.Ang La Salle naman kasi,puro pop usually...(my opinion)


And since Rock is better than pop and Ateneo produces more rock than La Salle....


Ateneo wins.



Go Ateneo!One Big Fight!  :evil:
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: roger_alcantara on October 31, 2006, 11:11:38 AM

And since Rock is better than pop and Ateneo produces more rock than La Salle....


Ateneo wins.



Go Ateneo!One Big Fight!  :evil:


ehehehe i admire your school pride. :p  in that case, OT ako, Manresa School pa rin! :))  nuns rock! wehehehehe!
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: Letour on October 31, 2006, 11:37:12 AM
I would like to add to this.

I went to Ateneo law and my post graduate law degree was from a Jesuit institution in SF.

I had a band when I was in Ateneo law. But none of them went to Ateneo undergrad nor high school and we played rock.

But my heart is where I went to high school and college. And both have red colors as their banner. So, go San Beda.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: sonnyrayvaughn on November 01, 2006, 08:52:45 PM
la salle siempre.. no questions asks!

Animo La Salle!!!

samba simba sam....

La Salle Spelling!!

hehe, sa cheer pa lang.. rock en roll na :)

teka, di ba mga taga batangas ang parokya? akala ko taga LS lipa sila.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: the emo poser on November 01, 2006, 09:43:01 PM
la salle siempre.. no questions asks!

Animo La Salle!!!

samba simba sam....

La Salle Spelling!!

hehe, sa cheer pa lang.. rock en roll na :)

teka, di ba mga taga batangas ang parokya? akala ko taga LS lipa sila.

Baka ngayon yon....Ateneo sila eh.Their bassist's father is my dad's brod from UP.......Ateneo nga yata talaga sila.

Plus,I saw their guitarist wearing an Ateneo jersey in thier music video"Oara Sa Yp".



Three Fights to the fight fight blue and white!

Fight Fight
Blue and White
Go Go Ateneo
Sis boom bah!
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: BassCog on November 02, 2006, 02:03:27 PM
Let's see, my band now (Cog) is from the Ateneo batches that had: Plane Divides The Sky, Boy Elroy (not sure if they had high school AHS members, though), Chicosci, Dicta License, Kjwan, Happy Meals, Greyhoundz (via Niño Avenido), Out of Body Special, Sponge Cola, Rampqueen, 13 Needles, and Day One Movement.

when I myself graduated from the high school, there were bands like the Happy Shrimps and Under Blue Skies (I think atenean ito). I later got into a band with Dale Ibay (Cookies for Kids) for a short while.

That's a lot of bands, and if I were to think like the classic Arrneean, I'd think, shet, dami yan! talo ang Lasalle.

But I'm not. that's a lot of bands, yes, but i have no idea, actually, of how many bands have come out from Lasalle - I never really kept track. It's possible that they have more bands out there, and I am inclined to think that they have more solo singers coming out of their alma mater than Ateneo does.

So should there be a rivalry? I think not. it's all music and musicians anyway - that ateneo/lasalle rivalry crap is just that: crap.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: Gep on November 02, 2006, 02:05:55 PM
la salle siempre.. no questions asks!

 :cry:
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: ortigas on November 02, 2006, 02:37:00 PM
So should there be a rivalry? I think not. it's all music and musicians anyway - that ateneo/lasalle rivalry crap is just that: crap.

I agree!!! Good one E.P. No questions asks!  :lol:

Off topic: http://www.topuniversities.com/worlduniversityrankings/2006/tables/201_520/
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: TheEdge on November 02, 2006, 02:41:02 PM
Olongapo/Pampanga produces great muscians no questions asked :D from Pepe Smith to AMO Band/The Boss and Rockstar etc. :D
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: Letour on November 02, 2006, 03:09:26 PM
I will add more fuel to the fire that is Ateneo vs. La Salle.

The best people to answer this question are those people who DIDN'T go to Ateneo or La Salle. They would be the best judge on who produces better (NOT MORE) musicians.  Naturally, an Atenean will never acknowledge the superiority of a LaSallite and vice versa.

Since I have an Ateneo post graduate degree, I must inhibit myself from making a list on who is better.

So, graduates of San Beda, UP, UST, CEU, UAP, AMA, and etc, SPEAK UP and tell us who are better musicians.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: daemonite on November 02, 2006, 03:16:22 PM
I have a question for you all....

Why is it that it comes down to where you studied pati sa music? It's bull enough that schools compete for the kill in sports, why music? I thought all the while musicians are born, not taught. Lessons are only there to harness the potential. I guess i thought wrong.

FYI: I am a self-made producer / musician / businessman here in the province and I didn't study at any universities mentioned. But why oh why did i accomplish my goals? It's not the school, it's the skills and determination i had to succeed.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: Letour on November 02, 2006, 03:33:44 PM
I have a question for you all....

Why is it that it comes down to where you studied pati sa music? It's bull enough that schools compete for the kill in sports, why music? I thought all the while musicians are born, not taught. Lessons are only there to harness the potential. I guess i thought wrong.

FYI: I am a self-made producer / musician / businessman here in the province and I didn't study at any universities mentioned. But why oh why did i accomplish my goals? It's not the school, it's the skills and determination i had to succeed.

Dude, I hear your problem. But this "question" will never die. It's in music as well. It might not be an actual "battle" but there are ads on TV now about a concert of LaSallian musicians headed by the Dean of the UP College of Music. I am sure there will be an Atenean concert to follow.

As for me, I had a band during my San Beda days. Coincidently, I went to a Bedan high school in the South. So, my music skills was because of my Bedan education. 
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: nevermindemily on November 12, 2006, 04:11:42 PM
Teka lang, di pa kami sikat eh. Iba-ibang college na kami ngayon ng mga kabanda ko, pero lahat kami galing DLSZ. Haha.

HAHA! ASA PA TAYO!!!
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: art_attack16 on November 12, 2006, 05:40:18 PM
marami din naman magagaling na taga uste diba??

saka sa PWU sa may taft... yun mga sumali sa battle of the bands sa PCU dati nun freshmen ako eh ang lulupet.. HIghway star.. saka BUlls on parade.. 2003 yun eh
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: jpadua on April 23, 2007, 10:50:22 PM

And since Rock is better than pop and Ateneo produces more rock than La Salle....


Ateneo wins.



Go Ateneo!One Big Fight!  :evil:


ehehehe i admire your school pride. :p  in that case, OT ako, Manresa School pa rin! :))  nuns rock! wehehehehe!

Oi Manresa ... si Bogs (drummer ng pupil) pati mga members ng The Teeth ;) ay oonga pala lasalle and Ateneo lang pala heheh...

Mga ka batch ko taga Zobel,

Mark Escueta (Rivermaya)
Nathan Azarcon (Bassist Bamboo)
Junji Lerma (Radio Active Sago Project)
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: dewberry on April 24, 2007, 09:19:03 AM
Sir RJ Jacinto ba Ateneo?
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: jpadua on April 24, 2007, 09:55:09 PM
Progressive music= ateneo

JUNJI LERMA (radioactive sago project, wahijuara, trip-M) MY IDOL AND TEACHER! ATENEO XD pero 2 years of college lang. he went to la salle sa gradeschool XD

Yeah, Idol ko parin si Junji Lerma! Batchmate ko sya from 1styr HS to 4rth sa DLSZ
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: Cressin on April 24, 2007, 10:28:14 PM
Ok, i came from neither high schools but i do have a lot of collegemates from these 2 schools right now (currently in ADMU which ironically is filled with LSGH guys haha don't worry i won't be biased)

The stereotype (according to my LSGH and AHS friends and they both  agreed with it) is that LSGH produce more singers like oggie alcasid while AHS produce more bands like kjwan.

But honestly i dont think these stereotypes really hold up. I have a classmate from LSGH who is a total shred god that can outshred all the AHS  axe-wielding men i know (then again i only know a handfull of AHS people so i wont really generalize that he can outshred AHS as a whole). Then again, i know a guy from southridge who can outshred him hehe (peace dudes) But yep. a lot of AHS guys are really in to progressive music.

Hehe but now as a whole, i can still say that it's really not in the school. I've heard really good bands from either sides eh. Some of which are tansan ni gaston from AHS and dalandan soda from LSGH  :-D

In the end, its not about the school dudes *peace!  :-D
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: almightymike on April 30, 2007, 09:36:14 PM
Animo!

Roselle Nava!
Champagne Morales!

hehe

napansin ko mas madaming pop(showbiz) ang galing lasalle.

baka mas magaganda kasi at mas pogi ang mga lasallista

no question asks!







Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: drummerboy827 on May 01, 2007, 08:39:41 PM
Paano naman Don Bosco Makati??????????
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: bakit? on June 10, 2007, 10:13:28 AM
up pa rin!
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: tejadster on June 11, 2007, 11:06:09 AM
lasalle - bloomfields
lasalle - jet pangan.... :-D
go lasalle
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: humbucker on June 11, 2007, 12:44:23 PM
ANIMO LA SALLE!  :-D
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: badongrodrigs on June 11, 2007, 02:19:46 PM
ooy nahukay nanaman ito! hahahaha

sad to say, Ateneo has produced more musicians.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: sjon014 on June 11, 2007, 06:52:06 PM
ooy nahukay nanaman ito! hahahaha

sad to say, Ateneo has produced more musicians.

As a Lasallian, aminado ako. Ateneo, UST, and UP have produced more musicians - ones that have made a mark (positive or negative) in the scene anyway. But there are a lots of green baby bands in the underground bar circuit. We'll get there... someday.
(All we need are better skills, better gear, an EP, a record label, then we're all set! Haha)
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: badongrodrigs on June 11, 2007, 07:06:27 PM
ooy nahukay nanaman ito! hahahaha

sad to say, Ateneo has produced more musicians.

As a Lasallian, aminado ako. Ateneo, UST, and UP have produced more musicians - ones that have made a mark (positive or negative) in the scene anyway. But there are a lots of green baby bands in the underground bar circuit. We'll get there... someday.
(All we need are better skills, better gear, an EP, a record label, then we're all set! Haha)

i disagree with you RE: ust and lasalle points :-)

i think UST and DLSU should change places in your paragraph above. i know a few known DLSU bands, however, the only bands i know that are partially UST are Hale and Join the Club.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: sjon014 on June 12, 2007, 12:34:15 AM
There's Publico, Paraluman... hehe. Fine! One thing that bothers me though, DLSU doesn't have a Conservatory of Music or an equivalent course offering. (Aside from the various orgs, anyway.)
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: badongrodrigs on June 12, 2007, 12:36:42 AM
One thing that bothers me though, DLSU doesn't have a Conservatory of Music or an equivalent course offering. (Aside from the various orgs, anyway.)

okey lang yun, wala din namang Multimedia Arts sa uste eh. hehe ay! wala ba? AHAHA kung meron man, i bet mas okey yung sa lasalle or csb.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: akosimic on June 12, 2007, 08:20:45 AM
ano ba ibig sabihin ng better musicians? mas humble? mas talented? mas pogi? mas matalino? or baka mas mabilis dumukot ng kulangot?

and i really do think we should let those who dont come from those schools answer.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: tejadster on June 12, 2007, 12:54:03 PM
There's Publico, Paraluman... hehe. Fine! One thing that bothers me though, DLSU doesn't have a Conservatory of Music or an equivalent course offering. (Aside from the various orgs, anyway.)
uy paraluman ito ba yung gitarista nila naka iceman. tpos yung vocals babae :?
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: harugrugrug on June 12, 2007, 01:08:24 PM
One thing that bothers me though, DLSU doesn't have a Conservatory of Music or an equivalent course offering. (Aside from the various orgs, anyway.)

okey lang yun, wala din namang Multimedia Arts sa uste eh. hehe ay! wala ba? AHAHA kung meron man, i bet mas okey yung sa lasalle or csb.

meron pang mithi,join the club at calallily sa ust di ba? mga tropa ko un..
sa conservatory e magoopen na din sa multimedia.. pero more of midi and stuff ata...ewan ko kung this yr o next year...
tska... antay niyo lang ang opening ng UAAP this july 7... puro musicians un ng UST at and diversity ng music na ippresent namin. kasama pala ako dun.. proud lang ako sa offers ng UST

pero DLSU and ATENEO... bow down din ako senyo... iba iba tayo ng mga trip at offers... diversity makes the music enjoyable... di ba? share share lang yan.. wag ng pag awayan.... cheers! peace...


Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: thinkfloyd on June 14, 2007, 01:56:02 PM
Coming from both schools, Ateneo produces more musicians... though in terms of being "better," I have no comment lest I be lambasted...
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: badongrodrigs on June 14, 2007, 04:26:06 PM
"BETTER" differs from one perspective to the next.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: bakit? on June 14, 2007, 07:42:29 PM
ooy nahukay nanaman ito! hahahaha

sad to say, Ateneo has produced more musicians.

in terms of?
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: badongrodrigs on June 14, 2007, 07:47:05 PM
ooy nahukay nanaman ito! hahahaha

sad to say, Ateneo has produced more musicians.

in terms of?

numbers. :roll:
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: kedysanchez on June 14, 2007, 07:52:39 PM
ooy nahukay nanaman ito! hahahaha

sad to say, Ateneo has produced more musicians.

Sir,

Why are you SAD TO SAY that Ateneo produced more musicians?  Would you be happier if La Salle  had more?
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: seyer on June 14, 2007, 07:56:50 PM
go ateneo!!
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: orgy18 on June 14, 2007, 09:15:04 PM
ANIMO LA SALLE!
ANIMO BENILDE! :evil:
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: bakit? on June 14, 2007, 11:22:01 PM
quantity/ok i get it.mas marami mas maganda.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: harugrugrug on June 16, 2007, 12:02:26 AM
this will never end.... hay.... pagdadasal ko na lang kayong dalawang skul..
pareho na kayong magaling... i respect both... pero hangang kelan kaya ito..
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: BassCog on June 17, 2007, 01:59:47 PM
this will never end.... hay.... pagdadasal ko na lang kayong dalawang skul..
pareho na kayong magaling... i respect both... pero hangang kelan kaya ito..

As long as people think that it matters in music. which I think is utterly funny.
Title: Re: La Salle HS vs. Ateneo HS - who produces better musicians?
Post by: Anthria on June 17, 2007, 05:29:30 PM
ooy nahukay nanaman ito! hahahaha

sad to say, Ateneo has produced more musicians.

As a Lasallian, aminado ako. Ateneo, UST, and UP have produced more musicians - ones that have made a mark (positive or negative) in the scene anyway. But there are a lots of green baby bands in the underground bar circuit. We'll get there... someday.
(All we need are better skills, better gear, an EP, a record label, then we're all set! Haha)

i disagree with you RE: ust and lasalle points :-)

i think UST and DLSU should change places in your paragraph above. i know a few known DLSU bands, however, the only bands i know that are partially UST are Hale and Join the Club.

I should have locked this.. way before....

... i gave you guys your chances...

..... i think it's enough..... :mrgreen:

this thread is locked