TALK @ PhilMusic.com - The Online Home of the Pinoy Musician
The Musician Forums => Pinoydrums => Topic started by: yoshiki21 on November 11, 2006, 09:32:48 AM
Title: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: yoshiki21 on November 11, 2006, 09:32:48 AM
we all know that these are all metal drummers, but which of em has the best style and technclity and chari :-)sm!!!!!
Title: Re: DEREK RODDY vs. JEOYJORDISON vs. DAVE LOMBARDO
Post by: pmack on November 11, 2006, 09:34:49 AM
Lombardo by a mile
Title: Re: DEREK RODDY vs. JEOYJORDISON vs. DAVE LOMBARDO
Post by: jun_BALARAW on November 11, 2006, 11:08:07 AM
di ko kilala yang lombardo.. wat band ba siya?
pero between roddy and jordison... syempre roddy ako.. pero pasikatan jordison syempre. hehehe
Title: Re: DEREK RODDY vs. JEOYJORDISON vs. DAVE LOMBARDO
Post by: pmack on November 11, 2006, 11:59:50 AM
what!?!?!? si Dave Lombardo pare yung original drummer ng Slayer. umalis siya sa Slayer nung 1992 then nag-experimento siya sa iba't-ibang banda (kasama na ang all-star band na Fantomas). nagbalik siya sa Slayer nung 2001. may bagong album ang Slayer, ang first album ng Slayer na kasama siya in over 15 years!
kung double-bass, creative fills and technicality ang pag-uusapan, doon ka na sa orig at pinaka magaling (imho).
peace!
Title: Re: DEREK RODDY vs. JEOYJORDISON vs. DAVE LOMBARDO
Post by: jun_BALARAW on November 11, 2006, 12:08:35 PM
what!?!?!? si Dave Lombardo pare yung original drummer ng Slayer. umalis siya sa Slayer nung 1992 then nag-experimento siya sa iba't-ibang banda (kasama na ang all-star band na Fantomas). nagbalik siya sa Slayer nung 2001. may bagong album ang Slayer, ang first album ng Slayer na kasama siya in over 15 years!
kung double-bass, creative fills and technicality ang pag-uusapan, doon ka na sa orig at pinaka magaling (imho).
peace!
ah slayer ba?? di ko naman kasi alam name ng drummer nun.. ngayon alam ko na hahaha... well mas magaling nga talaga yang lombardo na yan... dapat wag na natin siya isama sa thread na to, jordison at roddy na lang
Title: Re: DEREK RODDY vs. JEOYJORDISON vs. DAVE LOMBARDO
Post by: pmack on November 11, 2006, 12:35:42 PM
oo nga eh. hehehe... kasi siguradong siya panalo (sa tingin ko lang ha, hehehe)
Title: Re: DEREK RODDY vs. JEOYJORDISON vs. DAVE LOMBARDO
Post by: jun_BALARAW on November 11, 2006, 12:44:15 PM
Title: Re: DEREK RODDY vs. JEOYJORDISON vs. DAVE LOMBARDO
Post by: drumster on November 11, 2006, 09:40:02 PM
It's Dave Lombardo hands down!! This guy is a living legend... The Godfather of Double Bass Thrash Drumming... One of the most important drummers of the thrash/speed metal genre. He has inspired and influenced so many prominent drummers such as John Dolmayan, Josh Freese, Mike Wengren, Gene Hoglan, and many more. Even Jordison and Roddy would agree on this. Look for the September 2006 issue of Modern Drummer, for Dave Lombardo's cover feature.
I know these three drummers are great drummers... But it's like comparing Weckl and Colaiuta to... Buddy Rich! Lombardo is a myth in the double bass drumming world.
Title: Re: DEREK RODDY vs. JEOYJORDISON vs. DAVE LOMBARDO
Post by: lil.drummerboy on November 12, 2006, 08:54:37 PM
speed them all up and dont they just sound the same :?
*runs and hides*
correct. sa bagay kanya-kanya pa ring opinion yan. pero kahit 200bpm pa sila lahat pumalo, may ibang dating pa rin si lombardo. malalaman mo na siya agad yun.
*tago ako kasama ni peeves, sana kasya kaming dalawa*
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: autoexec on March 17, 2008, 03:19:48 AM
gusto ko lang sumabat.. Jordison! Creativity/Originaliry kay Jordison na ko. Parang tunog robot na lang kasi si roddy eh. Oo mas mabilis siya, pero parang paulit ulit na lang kasi siya eh... No offense mga bros opinion ko lang naman.. Iba si Jordison eh pakinggan nyo na lang yung album nilang "Live 9.0" kung hindi nyo pa napapakinggan. May lutong talaga. I can't wait to hear their new album to be released this year.. :-D
Di ko na nga pala sinama si Lombardo sa pinagpilian ko since senior/pioneer na siya at isa din siya sa mga main influences nung dalawa. para sakin di siya dapat kasama sa poll na ito.. hehe
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: oliver_soh on March 17, 2008, 08:08:57 AM
In my opinion id go for Roddy and Jordison,, :-D
Title: Re: DEREK RODDY vs. JEOYJORDISON vs. DAVE LOMBARDO
Post by: plep on March 17, 2008, 09:39:34 AM
It's Dave Lombardo hands down!! This guy is a living legend... The Godfather of Double Bass Thrash Drumming... One of the most important drummers of the thrash/speed metal genre. He has inspired and influenced so many prominent drummers such as John Dolmayan, Josh Freese, Mike Wengren, Gene Hoglan, and many more. Even Jordison and Roddy would agree on this. Look for the September 2006 issue of Modern Drummer, for Dave Lombardo's cover feature.
I know these three drummers are great drummers... But it's like comparing Weckl and Colaiuta to... Buddy Rich! Lombardo is a myth in the double bass drumming world.
+1
pure speed and agression in Reign in Blood... some of the best fills ever used in metal in South of Heaven and Seasons in the Abyss... proving he could still do it in Testament's The Gathering... then coming back and kicking pwet all over again with Slayer.
not to mention the unique approach to drumming he displayed with Fantomas. litsen to Director's Cut or Delirium Cordia... much more creative than anything Jordison and Roddy would ever come up with.
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: el Brutal on March 17, 2008, 09:44:41 AM
lombardo....legend !
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: Vorphalack on March 17, 2008, 10:06:24 AM
DAVE LOMBARDO!!!
he's on top of the drummer food chain. he'll just devour them all... that's my opinion of course. hehehe...
joey jordison and derek roddy are great drummers, among others too many to mention. they can hold their own. highest respect to them... :evil:
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: woodstockintheattic on March 17, 2008, 10:33:47 AM
Dave Lombardo anytime. His style has indeed influenced a number of metal drummers today. Among all the albums I enjoy his drumming the most in the South of Heaven album. Back then he was bad-ass and now he is even way more than that. In a recent interview he said that looking back on Slayer's older material he feels that he has improved so much more over the years and that is very evident indeed in the Christ Illusion album.
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: drummerboy827 on March 20, 2008, 09:56:04 AM
Lombardo. He has good insight/principles in the aspect of drumming. Plus veteran pa siya in double bass.
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: Tugpaktugpak on March 21, 2008, 12:16:02 PM
Dave lombardo astig yan....innovator eh
pero sa galing at style......syempre derek roddy
si joey jordison....ok lang magali din
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: gutblastgil on March 22, 2008, 05:26:33 AM
Derek Roddy: good in Death metal style, Blasting, speeding double bass playing..and some what fusion drumming narin...
Lombardo: good in rollings, stacato..
Jordison: New Age metal style sakto sa rollings at pedal..
"iba iba sila ng style. sori and no offense parang ndi tama itong thread na to.."
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: Paosin The Well on March 22, 2008, 03:58:00 PM
haha! triple threat match! i'd go for dave lombardo any day of the week, even twice on sundays!! like what you've all said, the guy's a living legend! slayer yun mhen!!!!!! on and on south of heaven!!!!! hehehehehehehhe.... :-D
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: metalmuhlisha on March 23, 2008, 04:27:59 PM
pure speed and agression in Reign in Blood... some of the best fills ever used in metal in South of Heaven and Seasons in the Abyss... proving he could still do it in Testament's The Gathering... then coming back and kicking pwet all over again with Slayer.
not to mention the unique approach to drumming he displayed with Fantomas. litsen to Director's Cut or Delirium Cordia... much more creative than anything Jordison and Roddy would ever come up with.
+2. pero [apple], kapag nakikinig ako ng (most of) mike patton works, feel ko masusuka ako e.
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: vanlyvan on March 23, 2008, 09:18:44 PM
dave lombardo na.. magaling na si dave lombardo pumalo habang si jordison naman, kinukulit pa ang magulang para ibili siya ng drumkit.. hehe! :evil:
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: toymach2000 on March 28, 2008, 05:28:57 PM
Lombardo for me. :-D Damn Rollings and grooves Roddy-Blastbeat maniacs Joey- A great drummer (scary clown to my brother) :lol:
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: omat17 on April 07, 2008, 02:26:18 PM
uhmmmm, jordison??? HEhehe???
Title: Re: Derek Roddy vs. Joey Jordison vs. Dave Lombardo
Post by: maralita on April 08, 2008, 07:43:53 PM