Sa tingin nyo OK lang ba mag pa SIGN kay Idol kahit.....

[sandythedrummer]

Sa tingin nyo OK lang ba mag pa SIGN kay Idol kahit ibang brand yung ipapa pirma mo??

Well naisip ko lang to kasi baka tayong mga pinoy lang ang ganito.

Magandang halimbawa yung clinic dati ni Billy Sheehan(Mr. Big's bassist using a YAMAHA Bass Of course) sa Yupanks may nag papapirma ng Fender Strat and shempre tumanggi sha pumirma.


Kayo anu stand nyo dito? Wala naman sigurong masama pero anu kaya issue regarding this?

Para kang nag pa pirma kay Kobe Bryant ng Jersey ni Lebron James.

[royalletones]

baka kasama sa contract nila yun. not to signed the brand/model na di nila iniindorse.

[kino]

Sa tingin nyo OK lang ba mag pa SIGN kay Idol kahit ibang brand yung ipapa pirma mo??

Well naisip ko lang to kasi baka tayong mga pinoy lang ang ganito.

Magandang halimbawa yung clinic dati ni Billy Sheehan(Mr. Big's bassist using a YAMAHA Bass Of course) sa Yupanks may nag papapirma ng Fender Strat and shempre tumanggi sha pumirma.


Kayo anu stand nyo dito? Wala naman sigurong masama pero anu kaya issue regarding this?

Para kang nag pa pirma kay Kobe Bryant ng Jersey ni Lebron James.

IMO respect na lang siguro nung mga artists sa brand that they endorse. So out of respect na rin, hindi OK sakin magpa autograph kay idol ng ibang brand aside from what he is endorsing. Sa tshirt or sa CD/DVD na lang ako magpa autograph. 

[kimboy]

yup, sa tingin ko na hu-hurt sila kpag ganun..

[Gep]

I'm guilty as charged. 

[hiskoolstudes]

depende siguro yun.

If you're going to have an item with a different brand signed by an endorser of another brand, he can probably do that in private but not an event that was sponsored by the endorsed brand in the 1st place.

[stick]

hehe ang awkward nun. it's like manning a coca-cola delivery truck with all it's coke cargo and coke embelishments and then you're seen drinking a pepsi from the inside. 

[lil.drummerboy]

siyempre hindi. pero depende din kasi kay idol. meron ako kilala dito satin zildjian siya pero pumipirma ng ibang brand ng cymbals..

[samscapular]

I'm guilty as charged. 

me too!!i had mike mangini signed my tama snare!hahaha pero nakatago sa case nung pnasign ko haha!Idol eh!

[kornbip99]

Para naring nagpapirma ka ng pirated na CD ni idol.

[sjon014]

Hmm. I guess it's okay kung hindi direct competitor ng ineendorse nya. For instance, if Akira Jimbo uses Yamaha drums - papasign ko skin ko. Actually pinapasign ko talaga unused/old heads ko. Yung bassist naman namin dati, ang pinapasign nya, yung strap nya.

[sandythedrummer]

hindi po ba pang anything goes na po etong usapan?

Hindi naman bro. Read the comments. OT lang yung mga example na binigay ko para hindi naman offending sa mga ka brod naten.

[firecracker_pop]

tingin ko kung nandun si idol para i-promote ang brand nya or clinic nya yun as an endorser nung brand, i guess hindi maganda mag pa-autograph nung ibang brand na item. pero kung concert yun para ipakita nya galing niya or to entertain, mukang wala naman problema, kasi as an artist yung lakad nya dun at hindi endorser. diba? diba? 

[kornbip99]

Hindi naman bro. Read the comments. OT lang yung mga example na binigay ko para hindi naman offending sa mga ka brod naten.

I understand what you're saying. Pero, IMHO, pag professional touring musician kasi, ang brand na ineendorse ng isang musician represents the musician itself kaya nga endorsement. Hindi ka naman papayag magendorse o maassociate sa isang produkto o kompanyang ayaw mo pag ayaw mo tlga diba? (well, not unless nagpapaka "sell-out" ka or kailangan talaga ng pera but that's a different topic na)

Lalu na kung may signature instrument pa yung musician na yun. Parang nagpapirma ka ng Travis barker drum sticks kay Thomas Lang. awkward. Kahit hindi signature series din ganun din.

Best to keep it within the family i guess. Pero cyempre, respect din. Di dahil si mike mangini at travis barker ay zildjian endorsers eh pwede ka na magpapirma ng barker drum sticks kay mike mangini na may sig sticks din.hahaha Pero malay mo, kung sobrang cool sila. magtropa si mike mangini at si barker kaya ok lng sa kanila. OR!!! magkagalit sila at papatungan ni mangini ang signature ni barker sa sig stick ni barker! hahahaha ang evil pala ni mangini! pucha!

[sandythedrummer]

I understand what you're saying. Pero, IMHO, pag professional touring musician kasi, ang brand na ineendorse ng isang musician represents the musician itself kaya nga endorsement. Hindi ka naman papayag magendorse o maassociate sa isang produkto o kompanyang ayaw mo pag ayaw mo tlga diba? (well, not unless nagpapaka "sell-out" ka or kailangan talaga ng pera but that's a different topic na)

Lalu na kung may signature instrument pa yung musician na yun. Parang nagpapirma ka ng Travis barker drum sticks kay Thomas Lang. awkward. Kahit hindi signature series din ganun din.

Best to keep it within the family i guess. Pero cyempre, respect din. Di dahil si mike mangini at travis barker ay zildjian endorsers eh pwede ka na magpapirma ng barker drum sticks kay mike mangini na may sig sticks din.hahaha Pero malay mo, kung sobrang cool sila. magtropa si mike mangini at si barker kaya ok lng sa kanila. OR!!! magkagalit sila at papatungan ni mangini ang signature ni barker sa sig stick ni barker! hahahaha ang evil pala ni mangini! pucha!

Bro sorry na miss quote ko yung reply ayan napalitan kona. Peace. Hindi para sayo yung reply ko.

[firecracker_pop]

Best to keep it within the family i guess. Pero cyempre, respect din. Di dahil si mike mangini at travis barker ay zildjian endorsers eh pwede ka na magpapirma ng barker drum sticks kay mike mangini na may sig sticks din.

tingin ko ok lang yang ganyan... pag uwi nga lang ni mike mangini, ikukwento nya kay travis barker na may mokong na nagpapirma sa kanya nung signature sticks ni travis... tapos magtatawanan sila. pagtatawanan nila ng todo. ayun... lahat masaya.

[kornbip99]

Bro sorry na miss quote ko yung reply ayan napalitan kona. Peace. Hindi para sayo yung reply ko.

hahaha no worries bro. I figured as much. No harm done!

[kornbip99]

tingin ko ok lang yang ganyan... pag uwi nga lang ni mike mangini, ikukwento nya kay travis barker na may mokong na nagpapirma sa kanya nung signature sticks ni travis... tapos magtatawanan sila. pagtatawanan nila ng todo. ayun... lahat masaya.

Pwede! hahaha tapos secretly galit pala si travis kaya sa next gig niya, mamimigay cya ng mangini sticks para after ng set pipirmahan niya lahat ng lumapit sa kanya na nakakuha nung sticks ni mangini. evil din pala to si travis! Ngayon ko lng nalaman. Pucha!   

[NiardicA]

Masyado kasing mabigat ang legal system sa states compared here.... contract binds... maybe its in the fine print.... (must read talaga toh)

[JDennis]

If you will analyze the thread title, it is a little contradicting. Kung idol mo sya talaga, dapat naka Dennis Chambers signature snare ka din at hindi ibang brand. I know pwede mo sabihin na mahal kasi at hindi pa ma afford for now. Well, in that case, be a little sensitive and forget about having your "other brand/series" snare signed by him. Don't put your "idol" on the spot. Medjo insulting kasi yun sa product he is endorsing. Maaring pagbigyan ka nya out of goodwill since you are a fan, depends how nice of a person he is but he might get in trouble for doing so because he is under contract and their is an exclusivity clause. It's either that or you might be the one getting the bad end, an embarrassing situation if he rejects signing it. Now, if you feel it is all worth it, then go for it and I wish you luck. The event itself is sponsored by the product he is endorsing. You don't want to see your "idol" reprimanded and probably even cause him his endorsement, would you? Besides, di din naman magandang bragging rights yun kasi di naman talaga nya signature product yung pinirmahan nya eh..magmumuka lang trying hard. Just like one poster said, ibang item nalang papirmahan mo. Maybe a stick, a cymbal bag, shirts, heads. Not sure about Remo though since Remo also manufacture snares. Kung wala talaga eh magpa kodak ka nalang with him and have it blown out at i-frame para display sa room or sa studio. Yun ang pinaka magandang bragging right. Kasi ang pirma pwede ma-fake eh. I know some would say pwede din naman ma-Photoshop ang picture pero that would be pathetic. Sensitivity and delicadeza are the key words here. I know how it feels, mahirap din talaga pigilan if the opportunity is right there in front of you pero kelangan natin gawin.

No offense meant to the OP. Just my opinion.

Cheers.

[nikogulo]

i think its better if the item you autographed is a brand that the artist is endorsing...but if you dont have any of the products he is endorsing i guess its fine as long its in the right place. kung clinic na sponsored ng let say zildjian, i dont think its proper to make him sign a sabian cymbal in that event. but if its a gig, i guess its fine.

[unnailed]

sir GEP pa autograp ng pearl ko and zildjians... hehehe joke...

[mylesthedrummer]

Siguro mas weird feeling for the artist. Kasi fan ka and aayaw sya.

Siguro maganda din plain shirt nalang. atleast mas valueable pa after..hehehehe