I was asked this very same question in 2001 or 2002. I voted for Chad since I had to study his odd signatures real hard in covering 311 songs. Otto's groove is, well, groovy. Pero Sexton ako sa creativity. Ayoko lang magdrums ng nakapaa.
Pero sabi nung nagtanong mas John Otto raw siya kasi, I quote, jazzer raw si Otto.
Hanggang ngayon, Sexton still has my vote.
Kahit pa mataba ako.