havent tried punching a hole on a 16" yet but here's what i do:
- use single ply heads on the drums
- i like the batter flappy and the reso side medium to loose, this gives me the click im looking for similar to RHCP's drums and less boom (a tip i learned from a fellow drummer)
- i use a samson qkick about 1" away from the center of the reso
and by the way, foot technique is more crucial than how you mic the drum. dont bury the beater on the head, it kills the sound too much