Just came from The Music Source today. I brought my Crybaby Classic to A/B it with the Artec APW-3. Kudos to the people at The Music Source for the great customer service. They even let me try the 5-watter Crate amp there. I didn't like it much, but good service nonetheless.
Alright, so in this A/B test.. other equipment I used included an off-the-shelf strat-style Aria guitar, and a (2x8?) Artec amp.
Construction-wise: Crybaby winsMaybe it's just me; nasanay na ko sa bigat ng Crybaby. The APW-3 is considerably lighter than the Crybaby.. and the metal enclosure feels different. IMO, it felt like plastic at first, but I remembered reading specs na all-metal nga ito. The APW-3's frequency range knob felt a bit too easy to turn for me. Maybe I was expecting the same resistance as the pots from Boss, especially because Artec used the same kind of knob. You be the judge if it's just because of my OC tendencies. Hahaha. Finally, the APW-3 makes me think of a Morley slimmed down to just a bit wider than a Crybaby.
Features: APW-3 winsThe Crybaby is pretty much a no-frills kind of wah. No LED indicator, not true bypass either. Then again, I haven't really noticed too much tonesuck from the Crybaby.
The APW-3 on the other hand, has a red LED indicator, no wah pot to wear out, as well as a frequency range knob. The range knob, as far as I can remember, mainly controlled the highs of the wah (toe position). It wasn't as drastic as I expected or wanted, but worked nonetheless. When engaging & disengaging the wah, I didn't have to press as hard as I had to on the Crybaby.
Soundwise: I'm having a hard time decidingI think everyone knows how a Crybaby sounds. As I expected, the APW-3 didn't have as much highs, or the 'shrillness' that others complain about. I also noticed that the sweep is a *tad* wider than the Crybaby. In addition, the APW-3's sweep is a bit more gradual.
Here comes the hard part - character. I'm not sure if it's because of the red Fasel inductor in the Crybaby, but the Crybaby has this
character that's hard to fully describe. Whatever position you have the Crybaby in, it seems to boost the frequency that it's focused on.. and as a result, it has this "gnarly" tone. On the other hand, the APW-3 felt & sounded a bit more tamed & smooth.
Generally speaking, the two wah's sounded similar. The APW-3, priced at 2,595 (if I remember correctly), is good value for your money. It can come close to my Crybaby.
What bothers me now is if I should sell my Crybaby Classic to get the Artec APW-3.
I have a love-hate relationship with the Crybaby's 'character', and I can't really decide if I can live without that or not. The Artec's price is really tempting.. especially because my music doesn't always revolve around the wah sound.
What do you guys think? Help me!