As nasty as you guys may think firemodel55 is, he does have a very strong point. not all local luthiers are equal. that is the simple and plain truth.
In the past when luthier wars were held here, the best conclusion was to try them all out and stick to who works best for you. they all have their indiosyncracies and approaches, and it is the celebration of individuality and availability of service that matters.
its great to know that mang max has stuck a chord among the many members here. that in itself is mang max's victory. alex is a passionate follower of arie, and i believe that arie is the big kahuna as he is without doubt the institution when it comes to lutherie. my personal fave is jon dela cruz of elegee, as i am supportive of his work. others swear by jun castro and mightek. they all started from scratch once upon a time too. nagkataon lang na wala pa philmusic when the earlier ones began, to weather the bashing
see the diversity? i'm not taking sides here, i wanna be objective as i can. i feel that crab mentality does the biggest damage on a start-up individual, as i see mang max has room for improvement. elegee had to carve his niche too, and his newer stuff is light years ahead of what he did earlier. what doesnt kill you makes you stronger, unless you allow it to kill you
but with due consideration to individuality, they are all not equals. strong in some areas, yes. with room for further improvement, absolutely.
take firemodel55's comments as encouragement in disguise . i'd hate to see this thread bombed.